I was consulting with a former collegiate athlete named Bill. He mentioned how his calves are always tight. So much so that his calves almost cramp when he is squatting or trap bar deadlifting. He told me stretching hasn’t helped. I said, “I am glad you are aware of that… stop stretching them.” He looked at me perplexed as if he wanted me to give him a different stretch to perform – hopefully a new and better stretch to fix his problem. I continued, “We can plan your exercise routine to make the tightness feeling subside. Think of the calve discomfort as overuse. We can create more movement options. Then, the strategy you have been using that relies on your calves, amongst other things, will not be overwhelmed. Thus, you won’t receive as much feedback from constant use of your calves.” Bill said, “The part about overuse creating discomfort makes sense, but I don’t understand how squatting or deadlifting uses my calves. Those work my quads, glutes, and hamstrings.” “Correct… they work everything. The body doesn’t work in isolated parts. So, the position of your body and your exercise technique determines the degree of stress in each area.” Bill took a moment to think and then stated, “So the way we exercise goes after the root of the problem. Otherwise, it’s just symptom management.” “Exactly!”
Everything Is Connected
All the bones, muscles, and tissues, like fascia, in the body form an interconnected web. One bone is connected to the bones adjacent to it via tissue, and those bones are connected to adjacent bones via tissue, and so on from head to toe. In fact, all of it is tissue made from the same stuff – mostly collagen. Everything is connected!
Think of a spider’s web. Where I to gently pull on one end of the web, the entire web would alter shape to some degree. The areas closest to my application of force would show the greatest change, and the deformation would decrease at each layer moving across the web to the other end. The human body is quite similar. The change is just subtle when not looking for it, and when only noticing the excursion of the limbs.
This model of an interconnected human has some major implications. First, changes in position of bones at one area of the human body impact position of bones, to some degree, even at the furthest location from the initial bone movement. Second, humans are not rigid lever dominant machines, like C3PO from Star Wars. The way we move is not with door hinge like joints and a pulley system of muscles. Moreover, chronic movement hindrances are not focalized joint problems per se – specific acute injury aside.
Humans have systemic movement, and thus systemic movement issues. When one joint or area of the body feels restriction, there are definitely other areas up and/or down the chain with limitation as well. In fact, the movement constraints above or below the area of concern are probably the major influence on the problem.
Limiting Movement
Muscle “tightness” is a feeling, and a symptom due to the “job” a muscle is trying to perform. The job of a muscle alters based on the position of the muscle, and the location of a muscle is in relation to the shift of the interconnected web of human tissue. Ideally, all of our tissue can continually alter in response to the context in which we are fighting gravity and moving our center of mass – aka being active. However, at some point the physical adaptations we make to create more strength may take away some movement of the interconnected web of tissues (read more about this here). The inability to change the position of all the tissues increases pressure in specific areas.
Bill’s calves are always tight because he is always pressing the front of his foot down into the ground -think about the ankle hinging to press on the gas pedal in a car. This a foot/ankle position to propel the body as if running. You can feel this yourself. Stand up and balance on the “balls” of your feet. Do you sense wanting to move forward? Can you feel yourself shifting your weight backwards to stay balanced?
Bill is always trying to move forward; especially while exercising to create more force like in a squat or deadlift. He is even biased this way while standing still! The discomfort in the calves is just one of the signs of the entire position of Bill’s interconnected tissues. There isn’t a barrier at the knee preventing the issue from cascading up the body, or vice versa.
Bill, like most active individuals, had altered the shape of his “spider web” to constantly shift his body weight forward because this helped him run faster and create more force in the weight room (read more here). Some of this shape change is needed for athletic performance. However, the pendulum has swung too far in his case. Bill is now constantly fighting his calves, and other propulsive strategies throughout his body, in moments he doesn’t need them. So he must learn how to better manage his movement options.
Move The Opposite Direction
Bill’s assessment showed a large amount muscle activity on the posterior side of his body. In particular, the lower hip area (picture the lower glute max) and below the shoulder blades (picture the “lats”). Essentially, this means he has to learn to put weight on his heels, and to move backwards. Based off his evaluation, I knew Bill would benefit from specific exercises and modifications like:
- “Core” exercises such as a bear hold with heels on wall and a yoga block between the knees.
- A toe touch with the forefoot elevated and a yoga block between the knees.
- A goblet squat to high box – yoga block between his knees and fully sitting on the box each rep.
- Staggered stance cable chops.
- ½ kneel 1 arm cable pulldown – back knee elevated.
These exercises will help teach Bill to keep his “spider web” shifted backwards while maintaining heel contact. Ultimately, allowing access to more movement options and a greater variety of pain free exercise.
Conclusion
Moving beyond the reductionist view of discomfort and joint motion limitations in the body, i.e. the calves feel tight so I have a calve problem, is needed to actually make change and not just mask symptoms. Viewing the body as one interconnected, malleable structure means exercise is a very precise endeavor. Every rep performed has whole body implications. Learning to master your individual movement strategies becomes incredibly powerful to your health, activity, and lifestyle.
Much of the time, managing the movement strategies presented by individuals like Bill is as simple as modifying an exercise routine. The first step is determining what YOUR tendencies and needs are. Then we can play with variables like the position of the external weight, how you position the limbs, and how you use joint range of motion to promote your physical changes. This way you can continue to perform the resistance training activities you love, limit the strain on muscles/tissues and joints, and promote comfortable movement for your fun physically active life outside the gym.
Contact us and let’s discuss how we can make your exercise more effective for your needs!
Cover picture from:
Bordoni, Bruno & Marelli, Fabiola & Morabito, Bruno & Castagna, Roberto. (2018). A New Concept of Biotensegrity Incorporating Liquid Tissues: Blood and Lymph. Journal of Evidence-Based Integrative Medicine. 23. 2515690X1879283. 10.1177/2515690X18792838.